The Hum of Hidden Danger
The fluorescent light hums at exactly 128 hertz, a frequency that starts to itch behind your eyes after forty-eight minutes of circular debate. You are sitting in a room that smells faintly of old coffee and aggressive ambition, watching three people stare at a credit application as if they can conjure the truth out of 10-point Calibri font. The applicant is asking for an $88,000 line. Their balance sheet looks like a polished marble floor-smooth, cold, and meticulously cleaned.
But there is a vibration in the room, that subtle, pre-catastrophic shudder you only feel when something is about to give way.
Outside this room, three blocks away, a competitor is closing a file on this exact same client. They are writing off a $38,000 loss. They aren’t talking about it. They are burying it in their quarterly report under ‘operational adjustments,’ nursing their wounds in private. They know the client is a ghost, a hollowed-out shell moving from one factor to the next, harvesting capital before the inevitable collapse. But you don’t know that. You are sitting here, testing the weight of your own pens-I’ve actually tested 48 of them this morning, searching for one that doesn’t skip-and wondering if you should pull the trigger on the deal.
Competitor’s Secret
Your Avoided Cost
The Tragedy of Silence
It is the great tragedy of the modern financial landscape. We treat our failures as proprietary secrets, protecting the very data that would save us from each other’s mistakes. We operate in silos of silence, assuming that by hiding our scars, we maintain a competitive edge. In reality, we are just waiting for our turn to bleed.
Omar G.H. knows this better than most. Omar isn’t a financier; he’s a carnival ride inspector who has spent 28 years crawling through the guts of Ferris wheels and tilt-a-whirls across the Midwest. He has a nose for structural fatigue that borders on the supernatural. I met him while he was inspecting a 1988 Zipper ride. He wasn’t looking at the paint or the lights; he was looking at the hairline fractures around the mounting bolts.
“
‘Everyone thinks the danger is the engine failing,’ Omar told me, wiping grease onto a rag that had seen better days back in 1998. ‘But the engine is loud. You know when an engine is dying. The real danger is the silence of the steel. One guy sees a crack in Ohio and fixes it, but he doesn’t tell the guy in Nebraska. So the guy in Nebraska keeps running the same ride until the steel snaps. We’re all riding the same physics, but we act like the rust belongs to us alone.’
The Physics of Hoarding
Business intelligence is often framed as a zero-sum game of secrets. We want to know things others don’t so we can win. But in the world of credit and risk management, the most valuable data is the information everyone else already has but refuses to say out loud. When you refuse to share the ‘rust’ you’ve found on a specific debtor, you aren’t gaining an advantage over your competitor. You are simply ensuring that the systemic risk remains high for everyone, yourself included. If the carnival ride collapses in Nebraska, the whole industry takes a hit. People stop going to carnivals. The trust evaporates for everyone, not just the guy with the broken bolt.
Risk Distribution in Siloed Systems (Illustrative)
I’ve spent the last 18 hours thinking about the way we hoard our mistakes. It’s like the pens I was testing earlier. Some of them felt perfect for the first eight words, then they’d just die. If I didn’t throw the bad ones away-if I just put them back in the drawer to let the next person discover their uselessness-I’m not being ‘competitive.’ I’m just being a nuisance to the future version of myself or my colleagues. Yet, in the high-stakes world of accounts receivable and factoring, we put the dead pens back in the drawer every single day.
Alpha vs. Beta
The Alpha
The unique insight that gives us the win. This is the search for proprietary advantage.
The Beta
The shared reality of the environment-the collective facts that determine survival.
We are obsessed with the ‘Alpha’-the unique insight that gives us the win. But in risk management, the ‘Beta’-the shared reality of the environment-is what actually determines survival. If you are the only one who knows a debtor is a fraud, you are ‘safe’ for now. But if you are the only one who *doesn’t* know, you are the one holding the $88,000 bag of air. The irony is that we spend millions on proprietary algorithms to predict behavior, while the actual behavior has already happened and is recorded in the ledger of a company across the street.
The silence of your competitor is the loudest warning you will never hear.
From Secrecy to Efficiency
This is where the paradigm has to shift. We need to move from a mindset of proprietary knowledge to one of collective intelligence. This isn’t about being ‘nice’ or ‘cooperative’ in a soft, altruistic way. It is about cold, hard efficiency. It is about realizing that the cost of acquiring a bad client is 8 times higher than the cost of losing a good one. When we crowdsource risk data, we aren’t giving away our ‘secret sauce.’ We are contributing to a global map of the minefield.
Omar G.H. once showed me a logbook he keeps. It contains the serial numbers of every defective part he’s found in nearly three decades. He shares that log with every other inspector he meets.
“
‘If I see a bad batch of 48-grade bolts coming out of a factory in 2008,’ he said, ‘I want every guy with a wrench to know that number. If the industry stays safe, I stay employed. If rides start falling over, I’m just another guy looking for work.’
In the factoring world, the ‘defective bolts’ are the debtors who systematically exploit the lack of communication between lenders. They thrive in the gaps between our silos. They know that even if they burn you for $208,000, they can walk into a different office on Monday and start fresh because your ‘proprietary’ loss is their ‘clean’ slate.
The Cost of Ignorance
I think about the 128-hertz hum of that credit committee room. That hum is the sound of people trying to solve a puzzle with half the pieces missing. They are looking at the client’s self-reported data, which is like asking a carnival operator if his own rides are safe. Of course he says yes. He’s got tickets to sell. The only person you should be asking is the guy who just finished cleaning up the oil spill from the last time that ride ran.
Why be the 29th to learn the lesson?
We have this strange obsession with ‘first-party’ data. We think if we didn’t generate it ourselves, it’s somehow less reliable. But experience is a brutal teacher, and its tuition is incredibly high. Why would you pay the full price for a lesson that someone else has already paid for? If a debtor is slow-paying 28 other factors, do you really need to be the 29th to find out? Is your ‘process’ so superior that you think you’ll be the one to magically collect from a stone?
The Barrier: Admitting Wrongdoing
The psychological barrier to this kind of sharing is immense. We are trained to hide our losses because they look like failures of judgment. If I admit a client took me for $18,000, I’m admitting I was wrong.
But the real failure isn’t getting hit; the real failure is allowing the person standing next to you to get hit by the same punch. When we contribute our data to a collective pool, we aren’t broadcasting our weakness. We are fortifying the entire ecosystem.
Omar G.H. standing under a massive steel support beam… He found a tiny mark… He told the owner to shut the ride down. The owner stopped screaming. The data wasn’t an opinion; it was a prophecy.
Resting the Gut
In our industry, we don’t have many Omars. We have analysts and spreadsheets and ‘gut feelings.’ But a gut feeling is just a reaction to an incomplete set of facts. When you have access to a database that reflects the actual payment behavior of thousands of debtors across the entire industry, your gut can finally take a rest. You don’t have to wonder if the ‘scratch’ on the balance sheet is a cat or a catastrophe. You can see the history of the steel.
The Peace of Crowdsourced Evidence.
There’s a certain peace that comes with testing all those pens and finally finding the one that works. It’s the same peace that comes from making a credit decision based on actual, crowdsourced evidence rather than a hope and a prayer. The cost of being wrong is too high to be borne alone. We are all inspectors in this carnival of commerce, and the rides are only getting faster and more complex.
The Final Reckoning
We have to decide if we want to be the ones who keep the secrets or the ones who keep the industry standing. I’ll take the shared logbook every time. I’ll take the warning from the guy in Ohio. I’ll take the collective intelligence that turns my competitor’s $38,000 mistake into my $0 saved fortune. Because at the end of the day, the only thing more expensive than a bad debt is the silence that allowed it to happen.
If you’re still sitting in that room, listening to the hum of the lights and wondering if you’re about to make a mistake, maybe it’s time to stop looking at the Calibri font and start looking at what the rest of the world already knows.
The Truth is Shared
The truth is out there, usually sitting in someone else’s ‘failed’ folder, just waiting for a place to be told.
Explore Collective Intelligence
